Where Are We in the Current Business Cycle?
How to Protect Your Investments in Any Phase
Many people who failed to recognize the state of the business cycle did not get out of the stock market before the Great Recession hit. Making matters worse, they fear to get back into the stock market at the beginning of an expansion cycle. That's the right time to do so.
While you can't time the market perfectly, you can improve your returns by getting better at reading the business cycle. You then can adjust your asset allocation to take advantage of the phases.
The line chart below shows how the business cycle can be used to plot the rise and fall of our nation's gross domestic product. It tracks the expansion and contraction of the U.S. economy after World War II.
- Expansion: The economy grows a healthy 2 to 3 percent. Stocks enter a bull market.
- Peak: The economy grows more than 3 percent. Inflation sends prices up. There are asset bubbles. The stock market is in a state of "irrational exuberance." Talking heads announce we are in a "new normal." Authors publish books with titles such as "Dow 30,000."
- Contraction: Economic growth slows but isn't negative. Stocks enter a bear market.
- Trough: The economy contracts, which signals a recession. Economic experts predict it will continue for years.
Since June 2009, the economy has been in the expansion phase. That's 10 years, as of 2019. Expansion phases last five years or so. As a result, many people are warning that a recession is just around the corner.
But there hasn't been troubling levels of inflation, which is the warning sign that expansion is reaching its peak. Instead of inflation, there are asset bubbles. In 2015, it was in the U.S. dollar. The weak demand for the euro contributed to a strong dollar. There was an asset bubble in housing prices right before the 2008 recession. Sometimes the irrational exuberance of a peak takes place in asset prices without generating overall inflation.
Economist John Kenneth Galbraith once said there are two types of economic forecasters: "Those who don't know and those who don't know they don't know." It's difficult enough to get an accurate read on where we are at in the business cycle. Figuring out where we are going months or years from now can seem next to impossible. Here are some common indicators to make the process seem less like guesswork.
- The S&P 500: This is a collection of 500 of the largest publicly traded stocks in the United States. The Dow Jones Industrial Average, by comparison, comprises only 30 stocks. As a result, the S&P 500 is a more thorough gauge of where the U.S. economy stands at any given time.
- Unemployment claims: The number of workers claiming unemployment benefits topped 10 percent in 2009, but it has dropped to less than 4 percent as of 2018. In general, rising unemployment rates are often seen as an indicator of trouble for the economy, and falling unemployment rates can be viewed as the opposite. As with all potential indicators, though, look beyond the surface. For example, the unemployment rate measures only those people who either are working or are seeking work. Those who are not working by choice are not counted. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the number of 16- to 24-year-olds not working because they are going to school has risen since 2009 while the unemployment rate has dropped.
- Consumer confidence: The consumer confidence index measures how willing people are to make purchases in any upcoming 12-month period. A rating higher than 100 means people plan to spend money, while a rating lower than 100 indicates that people are more likely to add to their savings and hold off on major purchases. The less willing people are to spend their money, the worse that can be for the economy.
- Housing: An increase in new construction or rising values for existing homes can be positive indicators for the economy and the business cycle. On the flip side, if new construction slows or existing home prices plateau, that can be a sign of trouble.
Remember that no single indicator should be viewed in a vacuum and you should always look deeper than the headlines. For example, new construction might be slowing because tariffs made imported lumber more expensive. Other indicators might still project a strong economy. Some other potential indicators worth tracking include commodities prices, the consumer price index, and the producer price index.
How to Protect Yourself in Each Phase
Consult a certified financial planner when you want to buy specific funds or stocks. Here are some guidelines for what tends to do better in each phase of the business cycle:
- Contraction: Sit tight. If you haven’t sold stocks by the time the economy contracts, it’s probably too late. You could move some assets into bonds or cash, but keep some in stocks. You want to catch the rebound when it occurs. Most investors sell stocks when the contraction is already well underway. They don’t buy them until it’s too late. A recession or bear market usually lasts six to 18 months.
- Trough: Start adding stocks and commodities such as gold, oil, and real estate. They should be cheap during a recession.
- Expansion: In the early stages of an expansion, small-cap stocks grow the fastest. Small companies are nimble enough to take advantage of a market turnaround. You can gain extra income with high-yield bonds. Add stocks and bonds from foreign developed and emerging markets. They hedge against a declining dollar. Emerging markets grow faster in the early stages of an upturn. For example, Brazil’s banks didn’t purchase subprime mortgages. Its economy grew when the U.S. economy was in recession. Emerging markets are risky, but as the global economy improves, that risk is worth it. Later on in the expansion, add mid-cap and large-cap stocks. Larger companies do better in the late stages of a recovery.
- Peak: Sell stocks, commodities, and junk bonds. Increase the proportion of cash and fixed income. The safest are U.S. Treasury bonds, savings bonds, and municipal bonds. When interest rates are high, buy and money market funds. As interest rates fall, a switch to corporate bonds provides a higher return with greater risk. Add gold until it's about 10 percent of your portfolio. It's a good hedge against inflation. It’s also the best protection during a stock market crash.
As you can imagine, it's incredibly difficult to sell stocks when everyone else is bragging about how much they're making. Timing the market is almost impossible. Instead, be conservative. Never have 100 percent of your investments in any one asset class.
Instead, make sure your investments are diversified. Gradually shift the proportion to stay in tune with the business cycle. Always work with a financial planner to make sure the allocation matches your personal goals.